Skip to content

Allan S. Broms

AKA: Allen S. Broms
Released
Gender:Male
Race:White
Era:1910s
State:Minnesota
Support
Socialism Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) Socialist Party of America
Allan S. Broms

Biography

Allan S. Broms, also known as Allan Strong-Broms, was a St. Paul Socialist and World War I draft resister. His civilian draft and antiwar-speech arrests preceded military confinement. Douglas records release from the 1917 workhouse episode by October 19, transfer into Fort Snelling military custody on January 28, 1918, and a twenty-year court-martial sentence followed by Leavenworth imprisonment. Sources conflict on his precise 1919 military discharge; the prior March 18 day is no longer treated as established.

Douglas distinguishes civilian draft cases from the subsequent military confinement: the St. Paul resisters’ civilian sentences were reduced to time served on January 28, 1918, and the men were transferred to Fort Snelling before Camp Dodge. The March 11 court-martial terms and subsequent Leavenworth transfers do not establish that those nominal terms were actually served. William R. Douglas, The Germans Would Court-Martial Me, Too: St. Paul’s World War I Socialist Draft Resisters, Minnesota History 55(7), Fall1997 pp286–301, original PDF page 3. Source: https://storage.googleapis.com/mnhs-org-support/mn_history_articles/55/v55i07p286-301.pdf#page=3

Douglas reports that Allan Strong-Broms surrendered on June 20, 1917 in the civilian draft-registration case. This initial custody preceded his separately described speech arrests and the January 1918 transfer to military detention. William R. Douglas, The Germans Would Court-Martial Me, Too: St. Paul’s World War I Socialist Draft Resisters, Minnesota History 55(7), Fall1997 pp286–301, original PDF page 6. Source: https://storage.googleapis.com/mnhs-org-support/mn_history_articles/55/v55i07p286-301.pdf#page=6

Douglas describes another arrest after an August 1917 speech at Lake Manuella. The narrative and reproduced flyer disagree about the exact August day, so only the month is recorded. A later September Minneapolis speech arrest led to workhouse confinement from which he was free by October 19. These are separate from his subsequent military custody. William R. Douglas, The Germans Would Court-Martial Me, Too: St. Paul’s World War I Socialist Draft Resisters, Minnesota History 55(7), Fall1997 pp286–301, original PDF page 11. Source: https://storage.googleapis.com/mnhs-org-support/mn_history_articles/55/v55i07p286-301.pdf#page=11

Portrait: rectangular crop from the individually identified historical photograph, original PDF page 13. Photographer not credited. Source: https://storage.googleapis.com/mnhs-org-support/mn_history_articles/55/v55i07p286-301.pdf#page=13.

Writing as a former fellow prisoner, H. Austin Simons describes Allen Strong Broms as a St. Paul socialist and former railroad office engineer who taught Efficiency in Propaganda and a series of sociology classes at Fort Leavenworth. Simons also recalled a farewell meeting before Broms’s release, at which the remaining prisoners asked him to work for their freedom. Source: https://www.marxists.org/history/usa/culture/pubs/liberator/1919/09/v2n09-w19-sep-1919-liberator.pdf#page=43

The Senate hearing compilation lists A. S. Broms in Minnesota under section 5 with an eight-month judgment dated January 14, 1918; the date is carried by a ditto mark from the preceding row. This is a civilian draft-registration entry, distinct from the existing antiwar-speech and military court-martial accounts. The table does not establish execution of this judgment, so no additional custody interval or time-served total is entered.

Amnesty and Pardon for Political Prisoners (1921), printed page 130 (PDF page 137).

Writing as a former fellow prisoner, H. Austin Simons describes Allen Strong Broms as a St. Paul socialist and former railroad office engineer who taught Efficiency in Propaganda and a series of sociology classes at Fort Leavenworth. Simons also recalled a farewell meeting before Broms’s release, at which the remaining prisoners asked him to work for their freedom.

The Liberator, September 1919, original PDF page 43.

Cases

United States Disciplinary Barracks, Fort Leavenworth
Charges: Disobeying orders; refusal of military service
Incarcerated: Jan 28, 1918
Sentence: Twenty-year military sentence, later reduced. Douglas documents transfer from the civilian draft case into Fort Snelling military custody January 28, 1918 and later Camp Dodge and Leavenworth confinement. A separate September 1917 workhouse episode had ended by October 19 and is not included as continuous military custody. Douglas places release about two weeks after May 6, 1919, conflicting with the previously stored March 18 day; the precise discharge remains unresolved. Source: https://storage.googleapis.com/mnhs-org-support/mn_history_articles/55/v55i07p286-301.pdf#page=15
Convicted: Yes
Institution State: Kansas
Charges: Disorderly conduct — utterances attacking the war (World War I speech prosecution, St. Paul, Minn.; 90 days)
Sentenced: Sep 28, 1917
Sentence: 90 days
Convicted: Yes
Charges: Refusal to register for the World War I draft
Arrested: Jun 20, 1917
Sentence: Douglas reports that Allan Strong-Broms surrendered on June 20, 1917 in the civilian draft-registration case. This initial custody preceded his separately described speech arrests and the January 1918 transfer to military detention. William R. Douglas, The Germans Would Court-Martial Me, Too: St. Paul’s World War I Socialist Draft Resisters, Minnesota History 55(7), Fall1997 pp286–301, original PDF page 6. Source: https://storage.googleapis.com/mnhs-org-support/mn_history_articles/55/v55i07p286-301.pdf#page=6
Charges: Arrest following an antiwar speech at Lake Manuella
Arrested: August 1917
Sentence: Douglas describes another arrest after an August 1917 speech at Lake Manuella. The narrative and reproduced flyer disagree about the exact August day, so only the month is recorded. A later September Minneapolis speech arrest led to workhouse confinement from which he was free by October 19. These are separate from his subsequent military custody. William R. Douglas, The Germans Would Court-Martial Me, Too: St. Paul’s World War I Socialist Draft Resisters, Minnesota History 55(7), Fall1997 pp286–301, original PDF page 11. Source: https://storage.googleapis.com/mnhs-org-support/mn_history_articles/55/v55i07p286-301.pdf#page=11